Based on your consumption of 27,000 – 30,000 kWh, the winner is unequivocally:
🏆 meckpommGAS 12s (Without Bonus)
Here is the detailed comparison explaining why the “cheaper” tariff with a bonus is actually more expensive for you:
| Feature | meckpommGAS 12s (Winner) | meckpommGAS 12 (With Bonus) |
|---|---|---|
| Arbeitspreis | 10,19 Ct./kWh ✅ | 10,78 Ct./kWh (+0,59 Ct.) |
| Grundpreis | 15,30 €/Monat | 15,30 €/Monat |
| Neukundenbonus | None | 207 € |
| Ø pro Monat (27k) | ~241,80 € | ~246,30 € |
| Ø pro Monat (30k) | ~264,78 € | ~270,40 € |
| Price Guarantee | Standard (12 Months) | Plus (12 Months) |
| Rating | 8,9 Fabelhaft | 9,0 Hervorragend |
💡 Why “12s” Wins at High Consumption
- The Math Doesn’t Lie: At 30,000 kWh, the price difference of 0,59 Ct./kWh costs you an extra 177 € per year. The bonus is only 207 €. You would need to stay with them for nearly 14 months just to break even. Since the minimum contract term is exactly 12 months, you will likely never fully profit from the bonus before the contract ends or prices change.
- No Repayment Risk: With “12s”, there is no bonus to repay if you move, cancel early, or miss a payment. At high monthly bills (~265 €), avoiding financial risk is valuable.
- Negligible Rating Difference: Both have excellent ratings (8.9 vs 9.0). The service quality is effectively identical.
- Identical Base Price & Term: Both have the same Grundpreis (15,30 €) and 12-month minimum term. There is no hidden advantage to the bonus version.
⚠️ When Would “12” Be Better?
Only if your consumption drops below ~11,500 kWh/year. Below that threshold, the 207 € bonus outweighs the higher working price. At 27k–30k, it is mathematically impossible for the bonus version to be cheaper.
✅ Final Verdict
Choose meckpommGAS 12s. It is the lowest-risk, lowest-cost option for your specific consumption profile. The bonus version is designed for low-consumption households and becomes a trap for high consumers like yourself.
No, eprimo Erdgas Pur does not have a Neukundenbonus (new customer bonus) or Sofortbonus.
According to the CHECK24 list you provided:
- Tarif: eprimo Erdgas Pur
- Arbeitspreis: 10,23 Ct./kWh
- Grundpreis: 15,53 €/Monat
- Sofortbonus: – (None)
- Neukundenbonus: – (None)
- Smily Punkte / Bonus: Only the standard CHECK24 Smily points/bonus apply.
️ Important Note for Your Switch
Since you are switching from NEW Energie and likely want to maximize savings at your high consumption level (27,000–30,000 kWh):
- eprimo Erdgas Pur is NOT recommended. Even though its working price (10,23 Ct.) is very low, it lacks the ~385 € bonus that makes other tariffs competitive. At 30,000 kWh, this missing bonus equals a permanent loss of ~32 €/month compared to bonus-heavy tariffs.
- Stadtwerke Schwerin (meckpommGAS 12s) at 10,19 Ct./kWh is still superior because it has an even lower working price and no bonus dependency risk. The 0,04 Ct./kWh difference saves you ~120 €/year vs. eprimo Pur, with zero strings attached.
Bottom line: For your consumption profile, avoid eprimo Erdgas Pur. Stick with meckpommGAS 12s as the optimal choice.
Based on the CHECK24 list you provided, no, 10.19 Ct./kWh is not the absolute lowest working price (Arbeitspreis).
There are two tariffs with a lower Arbeitspreis:
- E.ON Grundversorgung Erdgas: 9.97 Ct./kWh
- ⚠️ Warning: This is the Grundversorger (default supplier) tariff. It is marked as “nicht abschließbar” (not bookable via CHECK24). You can only get this if you have no contract at all and fall into default supply. Since you are switching from NEW Energie, you cannot select this.
- Stadtwerke Schwerin – meckpommGAS 12s: 10.19 Ct./kWh
- ✅ This is the lowest price available for an active switch.
- eprimo Erdgas Pur: 10.23 Ct./kWh
- Slightly higher than Schwerin, but still very low. (Excluded per your request).
Conclusion for Your Switch
Since the 9.97 Ct. tariff is not an option for a voluntary switch, Stadtwerke Schwerin (meckpommGAS 12s) at 10.19 Ct./kWh is indeed the cheapest bookable working price in your current list.
For your consumption of 27,000–30,000 kWh, this makes it mathematically superior to almost every other offer, including those with high bonuses like Vattenfall or eprimo.
At 27,000 kWh, the calculation shifts again. This volume is high enough that the Arbeitspreis (working price) dominates the total cost, making low-bonus/high-working-price tariffs uncompetitive, but not yet so extreme that every 0.01 Ct. difference outweighs a moderate bonus.
Here is the ranking for 27,000 kWh (excluding eprimo):
The Winner: Stadtwerke Schwerin – meckpommGAS 12s
(Best pure value at this consumption level)
| Tariff | Arbeitspreis | Grundpreis | Bonus | Ø pro Monat (27kWh) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| meckpommGAS 12s | 10,19 Ct./kWh | 15,30 € | None | ~241,80 € | ✅ Winner. Lowest working price wins at 27k. |
| BS ENERGY Spargas Plus | 10,68 Ct./kWh | 10,14 € | None | ~252,60 € | Solid runner-up, no bonus risk. |
| Süwag Gas Garant 100 | 10,76 Ct./kWh | 19,68 € | 243€ + 100€/yr | ~254,50 € | Price guarantee until Oct 2027 costs you ~12€/mo vs. Schwerin. |
| Vattenfall Easy12 Gas | 11,16 Ct./kWh | 19,90 € | 385 € | ~266,40 € | Too expensive at 27k. Bonus can’t compensate. |
💡 Why meckpommGAS 12s Wins at 27,000 kWh
- Working Price Dominance: At 27,000 kWh, each 0.01 Ct./kWh = 2,70 €/year.
- meckpommGAS 12s (10,19 Ct.) saves ~262 €/year vs. Vattenfall (11,16 Ct.).
- Vattenfall’s 385 € bonus ≈ 32 €/month, but the working price penalty is ~21,80 €/month. Net loss: ~10 €/month despite the bonus.
- No Bonus Risk: Since there is no Neukundenbonus, you avoid the “must stay 12 months or repay” trap. At 27kWh, your monthly bill is already high (~242 €); adding bonus repayment risk is unnecessary.
- BS ENERGY as Safe Alternative: If you want slightly lower Grundpreis (10,14 € vs. 15,30 €), BS ENERGY saves ~5 €/month on base fee but costs 0,49 Ct./kWh more = ~11 €/month extra. Net: meckpommGAS 12s still wins by ~6 €/month.
⚠️ Critical Threshold Warning
27,000 kWh is near the tipping point where bonuses become irrelevant.
- Below ~18,000 kWh: Bonuses matter significantly.
- Above ~25,000 kWh: Working price always wins unless bonus >400 €.
- At 27,000 kWh: Only tariffs with Arbeitspreis ≤10,30 Ct./kWh are competitive. Vattenfall (11,16 Ct.), Fuxx (12,21 Ct.), and all Biogas tariffs (>11,50 Ct.) are financially non-viable.
✅ Final Recommendation for 27,000 kWh
- Best Choice: Stadtwerke Schwerin – meckpommGAS 12s
- Unbeatable working price (10,19 Ct.)
- No bonus dependency → zero risk
- 8.9 “Fabelhaft” rating ensures reliable service
- Only Consider Süwag If: You specifically need price protection until October 2027 and accept paying ~144 €/year extra for that security.
- Avoid Completely: Any tariff with Arbeitspreis >10,80 Ct./kWh. At 27,000 kWh, these will cost you 200–400 € more per year regardless of bonuses.
Note: Double-check your actual consumption via last year’s Jahresabrechnung. If it’s actually 24,000 kWh or below, re-evaluate Vattenfall; if it’s 28,000+, meckpommGAS 12s becomes even more dominant.
Based on your annual consumption of 30,000 kWh, the calculation changes significantly. At this higher volume, the Arbeitspreis (working price per kWh) becomes far more important than the basic price or one-time bonuses.
Here is the re-evaluation for 30,000 kWh:
The New Winner: Stadtwerke Schwerin – meckpommGAS 12s
(Excluding eprimo as requested)
| Tariff | Arbeitspreis | Grundpreis | Bonus | Ø pro Monat (30kWh) | Why it wins at 30kWh |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| meckpommGAS 12s | 10,19 Ct./kWh | 15,30 € | None | ~264,78 € | Lowest working price in list. No bonus risk. |
| Vattenfall Easy12 Gas | 11,16 Ct./kWh | 19,90 € | 385 € | ~282,40 € | 0,97 Ct./kWh more expensive = ~291 €/year loss vs. Schwerin |
| Süwag Gas Garant 100 | 10,76 Ct./kWh | 19,68 € | 243 € + 100€/yr | ~275,60 € | Better guarantee but still 0,57 Ct./kWh pricier |
| BS ENERGY Spargas Plus | 10,68 Ct./kWh | 10,14 € | None | ~273,80 € | Close second, but slightly higher working price |
💡 Key Calculation Logic for 30,000 kWh
At 30,000 kWh, every 0,01 Ct./kWh difference equals 3,00 € per year.
- meckpommGAS 12s saves you ~17,60 €/month compared to Vattenfall solely due to the lower working price.
- Even with Vattenfall’s 385 € bonus spread over 12 months (~32 €/month), the working price disadvantage (0,97 Ct./kWh × 30,000 = 291 €/year ≈ 24,25 €/month) completely wipes out the bonus advantage.
- Süwag has a longer price guarantee (until Oct 2027), but at 30,000 kWh, the 0,57 Ct./kWh premium costs you ~171 €/year, which takes nearly 2 years to recoup via the bonus.
⚠️ Critical Warning for High Consumption
Avoid high-working-price tariffs regardless of bonuses. Tariffs like Fuxx-Spar Optimal (12,21 Ct.), PlusStrom Smart Gas (13,85 Ct.), or SAUBER GAS Bio100 (19,16 Ct.) are financially disastrous at 30,000 kWh. A 1 Ct./kWh difference at this volume equals 300 €/year. Never let a large Neukundenbonus distract you from the Arbeitspreis when your consumption exceeds 20,000 kWh.
✅ Final Recommendation for 30,000 kWh
- Best Overall: Stadtwerke Schwerin – meckpommGAS 12s
- Lowest working price (10,19 Ct.)
- No bonus dependency → no risk if you move or cancel early
- Solid 8.9 “Fabelhaft” rating
- Best Long-Term Security: Süwag Gas Garant 100
- Only choose this if you specifically want price protection until October 2027 and are willing to pay ~171 €/year extra for that security.
- Avoid Vattenfall Easy12 Gas at this consumption level unless you value brand service over pure cost savings. The math simply doesn’t work at 30,000 kWh.
Note: Always verify your exact meter reading and confirm the 30,000 kWh estimate before signing, as even a 2,000 kWh deviation shifts the optimal tariff.